2017 P Penny Value – Worth, Errors, and Rarity

For the Mint’s 225th anniversary, Philadelphia added a tiny “P” under the date, the first (and only) time that’s ever happened on this denomination. Most finds are still worth a cent, sure, but top-end certified Reds and legit mint errors can be pretty valuable. 

What you need to know is how to define those coins. For example, some people use a free old coin value checker or read guides about it online, we offer you to do both, and also to visit a specialist to confirm.

After this article you can have deeper reads like Top 25 Most Valuable Pennies to Look For.

Fast facts 

The 2017 P penny is the only Lincoln cent from Philadelphia with a “P” under the date, done for the Mint’s 225th anniversary.

• Mintage: about 4.36 billion, the piece itself isn’t scarce

• 2017 penny value (typical): face value in circulation; raw shiny “RD” pieces may cost a bit more

• Certified gems (MS67–MS68 Red) and genuine 2017 penny errors is what has much bigger price

• 2017 penny no mint mark? Re-check the date area, 2017 Philly should show a P; 2018+ went back to no mint mark

• Design: Lincoln Shield reverse (2010-present), copper-plated zinc planchet

Quick ID & Specifications

Those “guide numbers” you see online can be optimistic; check recent sold listings if you’re buying, and don’t pay top-pop money for mid-pop coins.

2017 P Penny Value by Variety

Practical retail ranges for typical coins 2017 penny with a P would be more valuable in your collection.

Millions of modern proof cents exist in top grades; the 2017 P Lincoln penny in superb Red business strike or an error is more rare to meet.

Errors & Varieties

Modern copper-plated zinc can look “weird” after a few years in pockets. It can get bubbles, spots, and stains that aren't mint errors. Stick to these:

If you’re new to errors and want a photo-heavy primer on what real mistakes look like (and what they sell for), check Coins Go Wrong: 20 Error Pennies That Could Make You Rich.

• Start with fresher sources. The best candidates usually come from 2017 mint sets and original bank-wrapped rolls. Circulated examples from pocket change tend to be nicked up, spotted, or dull. Unopened rolls and mint packaging give you the highest chance of seeing that glowing “fresh strike” look

• Color first. Collectors prize “RD” (full red) examples: bright, fiery copper tones that look almost new. Everyone looking for copper darkens to brown. If you see carbon spots, streaks, or even a single dark fleck, move on. Color is a make-or-break factor in modern cents

• Check the luster. Tip the coin under a desk lamp or flashlight. A quality piece shows cartwheel luster: smooth, uninterrupted circles of light spinning across the surface. Breaks, dull patches, or haze kill eye appeal

• Know the high-hit zones. Look closely at Lincoln’s cheek and jaw, the open fields, and the sharp corners of the Union Shield. These spots pick up contact marks easily. Even one obvious gouge in the open field can hold a coin back from MS67

• Evaluate strike quality. On the reverse, read the scroll: ONE CENT should be crisp, with no mushiness. The bar across the top of the shield should meet the vertical stripes cleanly. Weakly struck letters or blurry details mean less demand from picky collectors

• Watch for zinc. Since 1982, cents have been copper-plated zinc. That means plating bubbles, tiny pinholes, or streaky color can appear. These aren’t mint errors, but flaws, and they drag value down quickly

• Handle and store correctly. Once you’ve picked a candidate, don’t ruin it. Use cotton gloves or hold coins only by the rims. Slip them into inert holders (like Mylar flips or capsules) and store in a cool, low-humidity environment. Zinc reacts badly with moisture, so a damp basement is a recipe for spots and rot

Not in 2017, but learning design diagnostics on modern cents is useful, see the “Wide AM” discussion for 2000 issues.

Grading and Certification 

Business strikes in MS67RD 2017 Lincoln penny sell regularly; MS67+RD can justify fees; MS68RD is if the coin is truly flawless. Clearly diagnostic errors (bold cud, big off-center, strong doubled die) also warrant submission.

When to hold off:

• Average uncirculated pieces. If the surfaces show a few contact marks, the color is leaning toward red-brown instead of full red, or there are scattered carbon specks, the grade ceiling is limited. At best you’re looking at a mid-level Mint State, which sells for less than it costs to slab. The same goes for examples with hazy luster or uneven toning, they won’t excite buyers, even in a holder

• Tiny imperfections. Small die chips tucked into letters, little raised dots along the devices, or the flat, shelf-like look of machine doubling can be fun to spot under magnification. They make good teaching pieces, but they’re not the kind of features that third-party grading companies recognize as value drivers. Submitting them adds expense without increasing resale

• If you’re hesitating, you probably already know the answer. Grading makes sense only for razor-sharp, spot-free red examples with a real shot at MS67 or higher, or for unmistakable mint errors

Prep before you ship:

• Never “improve” the coin: no wipes, dips, or rubs

• Photograph both sides; note the variety/error on your submission form; pick economy tiers to keep costs sane

• Think like a seller: keep your total cost basis (coin + shipping + grading + selling fees) below realistic sale price for that grade

Final Thoughts

The 2017 penny worth a lot if it’s first and only “P” for Philly on a cent, flawless Reds and real mint errors. Most finds are still face value, so aim high. Hunt clean surfaces, crisp strikes, and unmistakable errors, protect them well.

FAQs

Related Coin Value Guides

• 1977 Dime Coin Value
• 1975 Dime Coin Value
• 1980 Dime Coin Value
• 1971 Quarter Coin Value 
• 1952 Quarter Coin Value 
• 1939 Silver Quarter Coin Value