Early American Coins: History, Value & Rare Colonial Finds

Early American Coins: History, Value & Rare Colonial Finds

How many fascinating stories, myths, and legends may lie behind the beautiful coin gleaming in your hand? Have you ever thought about the early US coins and the events that had to unfold for people to finally have a convenient and reliable means of payment?

How many fascinating stories, myths, and legends may lie behind the beautiful coin gleaming in your hand? Have you ever thought about the early US coins and the events that had to unfold for people to finally have a convenient and reliable means of payment?

American numismatics is full of fascinating stories, and for many people, collecting is an opportunity to feel the past and learn how the financial system of the country was formed. Let us explore US colonial coins, check coin value, and reveal what it was like at the beginning of the US formation.

A picture of 30 original and authentic coins from America displayed as part of a world coins collection.

What Was Used Before Official Coins Appeared

Although the United States declared its independence in 1776, it took many years before the nation established its own coinage system. The first US coins appeared only in 1792 with the adoption of the Coinage Act. But what other objects and foreign coins served as early US currency before? Colonial economies could not rely on just one form of money, and each region used what it had at its disposal.

Some examples of currency included:

Currency

Used By

Interesting Fact

Spanish Real

Traders

It was often cut into 8 pieces for convenient payments.

Tobacco

Virginia planters

Tobacco was officially used as currency until the 1700s.

British pound

Official currency until 1776

It was used as a standard for payment to foreigners.

Rum

Sailors and harbor workers

Used not only for payments, but also for payoffs.

Dutch Guilder

Merchants in New York

In the Dutch colonies, it was considered a reliable coin.

Fur

Frontier settlers and traders

Beaver furs were one of the most valuable assets.

Thus, silver and gold coins from various European countries used in circulation further became the basis for the first American coins and their denominations.

American Colonial Coins and Currency of Other Forms

Although each colony had its own means of payment, some options might have been considered relatively common (or, at least, widespread). In fact, there were different types of colonial era US coins, namely Massachusetts Silver Coins, Pre-1776 States releases, creations of French colonies, Proposed National Issues, Washington Pieces, and more. Here are particular instances to look for:

New England Silver Coins

A picture of a rare 1652 New England threepence coin featuring a simple punched design with "NE" and Roman numerals.

Years of Mintage: 1652

Denomination: Pine Tree Shilling, Sixpence, Threepence

Estimated Value: up to $2,520,000 

Composition: 100% silver

Design Features: The earliest silver instances struck in what would become the United States are extremely rare and historically significant. The first issues, minted in 1652 in the Massachusetts Bay Colony, were hand-punched with a minimalist design: one side bore the initials “NE” (for “New England”), while the other displayed the denomination in Roman numerals, i.e., III for threepence, VI for sixpence, and XII for shillings.

New Jersey "St. Patrick" Coins

A picture of a 1670s New Jersey 1/4 penny Saint Patrick coin in silver, showing the kneeling king with harp and crowned reverse.

Years of Mintage: 1670s

Denomination: Halfpence, Farthings

Estimated Value: up to $184,000

Composition: Copper

Design Features: The obverse features a crowned monarch (possibly King David or Charles II) kneeling and playing a harp, gazing upward at a floating crown. The reverse varies by denomination:

  • On the Farthing, St. Patrick is shown driving serpents into the sea.

  • On the Halfpenny, St. Patrick is depicted standing amid a crowd of people, raising his hand in blessing. 

American Plantation Tokens

A picture of an original 1688 American Plantations 1/24 real token featuring a crowned bust and shielded harp design.

Years of Mintage: 1688

Denomination: 1/24 Part Reals (Breen), 1/24 Reals (Akers), Farthings, etc.

Estimated Value: up to $32,900

Composition: 97.5% Pure Tin

Design Features: The obverse typically shows a crowned bust of King James II with the inscription “IACOBVS II DEI GRATIA.” The reverse features crowned shields and a harp representing Ireland.

Rosa Americana Coins

A picture of a 1723 Rosa Americana halfpenny with a crowned portrait and regular strike details.

Years of Mintage: 1722-1724

Denomination: Twopence, Pence, and Halfpence

Estimated Value: up to $28,800

Composition: Bath Metal

Design Features: The Rosa Americana series was minted under the authority of the British government to facilitate trade in the American colonies, with the obverse featuring the right-facing profile of King George I of England and the reverse displaying a crown on a rose.

Sou

A picture of a 1767-A Sou coin with a regular strike, featuring a hand of justice and scepter on the obverse and a crowned coat of arms on the reverse.

Years of Mintage: 1670-1764 (approximately)

Denomination: Often equivalent to a few pennies

Estimated Value: up to $504,000

Composition: Copper or Brass

Design Features: The obverse displays four lines of text in the field, positioned beneath a hand of justice and a scepter fleurdelisé crossed and tied with a ribbon. The reverse features a crowned coat of arms, symbolizing royal authority.

Fugio Cent: The First Official US Coin

A picture of a 1787 Fugio cent with a cross after the date, featuring the sun and sundial design with the “Mind Your Business” motto.

The first official coin minted in the US, the Fugio, was issued in 1787, before the adoption of the Constitution. It was named after “fugio”, which means "I run" in Latin. The unusual inscription symbolized the idea that time does not stand still and life is passing quickly.

Description and symbolism of the coin:

  • The obverse displays sunlight falling on the dial and the inscription “Mind Your Business”.

  • The reverse illustrates 13 rings connected to each other, symbolizing the original states. Inside the chain was the inscription “We Are One”.

Early United States Coins

1792 Half Disme

A picture of a 1792 Flowing Hair half dime, also known as a half disme, featuring Liberty with flowing hair and early U.S. mint styling.

The first coin after the passage of the act was the Half Disme. The coin (with the denomination of 5 cents) was struck in silver and had a small size (approximately 17.5 mm in diameter and weighing about 1.35 grams). The obverse of the coin was decorated with a bust of Liberty, and the reverse depicted an eagle with spread wings. 

According to rumors and legends, George and Martha Washington are directly related to the creation of the coins, as the coin was minted from the First Lady's silver jewelry, though there is no direct evidence of this fact.

Related article: The American Innovation Coin

Further Steps

After 1972, the Mint issued new denominations, e.g., half cent and cent (copper); half disme and disme, quarter, half dollar and dollar (silver); Quarter Eagle - $2.50, Half Eagle - $5, and Eagle - $10 (gold).


Issue

Metal

Design

Features

Estimated Value

1793 Chain Cent

Copper

Obverse: Bust of Liberty with loose hair

Reverse: Chain with 15 rings

The 15-link chain symbolized the union of the states, but quickly attracted criticism (chain=slavery)

$5,000 - $500,000

1793 Wreath Cent

Copper

Obverse: Bust of Liberty

Reverse: wreath with ribbon

Only a few surviving variants are known

$5,000 - $400,000

1794 Liberty Cap Cent

Copper

Obverse: Bust of Liberty in Phrygian cap

Reverse: Wreath

One of the best known early types of the 1 cent.

$2,000 - $250,000

1794 Flowing Hair Dollar

Silver

Obverse: Liberty with loose hair

Reverse: Small Eagle

First United States dollar, limited edition. One of the rarest and most expensive coins ever minted

$200,000 - $10,000,000

1795 Eagle ($10)

Gold

Obverse: Liberty with turban

Reverse: Eagle with spread wings

The first gold Eagle of the United States.

$50,000 - $3,000,000

1796 Draped Bust Quarter Dollar

Silver

Obverse: Bust of Liberty

Reverse: Small Eagle

First issue of quarters with the design of a bust of Liberty on the obverse

$10,000 - $500,000

1796 Draped Bust Half Dollar

Silver

Obverse: Bust of Liberty

Reverse: Small Eagle

One of the earliest half dollars with scarce mintage

$25,000 - $1,000,000

1795-1798 Half Eagle ($5)

Gold

Obverse: Liberty with turban

Reverse: Small Eagle

One of the first gold coins of the United States

$25,000 - $800,000

1804 Dollar

Silver

Obverse: Bust of Liberty

Reverse: Eagle with shield

The most famous and one of the rarest coins in the world

$1,000,000 - $10,000,000+

Coins Changed History

Colonial American coins tell the story of the development and economic independence of a young country. They are the most valuable and sought-after collectibles due to their unique characteristics, limited circulation, and low mintages. 

However, the valuation and identification of any coins requires experience and trusted tools. So, fast-paced collectors may rely on coin dealers or tools like Coin ID Scanner to identify and value coins from all over the world, accessing information in seconds.

Related Coin Value Guides

Find out for sure in
our app

coin icon

"Is that" your coin?

Find out for sure in our app

Find my Coin